American Numismatic Association American Numismatic History anti-counterfeiting C.H. Patten Collection Dealers and Companies Editors Choice Federal Trade Commission George Scanlon Grading Coins Harvey Stack Harvey Stacks Hobby Protection Act Ken Bressett Larry Stack Massachusetts Historical Society Nate Smith Collection News Numismatic History Numismatic Personalities People Recent Articles & Video Reed Hawn Richard Yeoman Stack's Stack's Bowers stacks Stacks Bowers

Harvey Stack – Growing up in a Numismatic Family: The Early Days of Stack’s – 1973

Harvey Stack - Growing up in a Numismatic Family: The Early Days of Stack’s – 1973

By Harvey Stack – Co-Founder, Stack’s Bowers Galleries ……
The yr 1973 noticed a quantity of initiatives for modifications in Numismatics.

With inflation persevering with and cash turning into extra out there however dropping its buying energy, all markets–from the Inventory Market to commodities, to actual property as properly–confirmed indicators that sure collectibles have been coming into demand and that folks needed to have some alternate means of funding or a “store of Value”!

As such, professionals and collectors labored to make the interest of Numismatics extra pleasurable, curbing the abuses of counterfeiters and promoters who tempted many to make dangerous investments.

A number of essential occasions occurred this yr. Stack’s (with me as a consultant) labored with america Congress on the Interest Safety Act; the American Numismatic Affiliation (ANA) reformed the grading system to incorporate numerical grading; my son, Lawrence R. Stack (Larry), joined the agency after his commencement from Ohio College; and we provided for public public sale an necessary group of previous-time collections. In different phrases, we had a very lively and necessary yr.

1973 was a yr when the significance and reliability of the skilled numismatist have been mentioned and acted upon. It was a yr of change to make the interest extra acceptable to the previous in addition to new collectors. The neophytes wanted steerage, the older, extra seasoned collector (who studied numismatics and discovered a lot about coin accumulating) wanted steerage as to the right way to develop with the enlargement of the pastime.

The Pastime Safety Listening to and Act

With the world financial system shifting in the direction of higher inflation, forgeries of all collectibles, from cash to stamps to antiques to work, have been being shipped worldwide. And in our pastime COUNTERFEITS and/or COPIES have been made to be marketed to the general public as real examples.

Congress obtained complaints concerning the lack of regulation and imitations have been made right here in addition to many locations worldwide. They convened a listening to to evaluate what the varied industries would recommend. I used to be requested to be the consultant for numismatic collectibles since my earlier encounter with the Treasury relating to the momentary restriction of gold cash from overseas. I did current my case, which included advising Congress that counterfeiting was flooding the nation and that we would have liked a strategy to regulate to influx. The Customized Home, I discovered, was ailing-outfitted to determine and confiscate false cash, and the regulation, which was lastly enacted, stated that each one cash getting into our markets which might be false and counterfeit needed to be stamped, in letters that have been clearly legible, the phrase COPY!

The similar issues, in alternative ways, affected “all collectibles”. From reproductions of antiquities to trendy artwork, from lithographs to porcelain, from jewellery to postage stamps, counterfeits have been discovering their approach into outlets, galleries, and even in small-city vintage outlets. And when the gadgets have been challenged, the customer had immense hassle getting his a refund. It was previous time that the Federal authorities have been armed for the battle with laws.

The Interest Safety Act was handed in 1973, turning a lot of the authority over to the Federal Commerce Fee (FTC) to suggest a set of laws and implementing guidelines. Nevertheless, the FTC was not capable of administer the regulation, for that they had few certified personnel to assist implement it.

So the regulation exists, however as late as 2014 few if any laws have been administered and enforced. To today, aside from the legal guidelines about counterfeiting (which have been on the books nearly because the nation started), the issue has not been regulated because the regulation supplies.

What appeared to work, which was very hindering and time-consuming, was the GOLD IMPORT REGULATIONS OF 1961 when an embargo was imposed on gold coin imports and particular licensing was required. Sadly, the federal government’s rulings have been arbitrary and capricious and rejected by the importers. Regulators have been unable, as a result of of a minuscule employees, to manage the laws and the import necessities have been terminated in 1967.

However all who participated in the hearings knew that the issue existed however had skilled a lot problem making an attempt to apprehend the culprits. Few cash have been stamped, whereas hundreds got here to market, and the Secret Service has had an inefficient employees to manage the laws. So the market has many false copies and counterfeit cash to cope with, and we in the interest have tried, typically efficiently, to cease the import and distribution of false cash. We maintain making an attempt!

The ANA and Grading Reform

The abuses in grading had develop into increasingly more obvious. So in the spring of 1973, the AMERICAN NUMISMATIC ASSOCIATION invited a group of over 50 professionals, together with myself, to Colorado Springs to deal with the varied methods utilized by collectors and sellers to grade cash, and to unify them so that each one cash would comply with the identical methodology.

Skilled sellers had many a dialogue about beforehand graded cash, as to what grade they’re, are they actually Mint State, are they Proofs or Proof-like, and so on., and there was many a debate about what grade a coin was or if it was truly higher or worse than recognized. The requirements are totally different for every denomination and mint. Know-how did differ, enchancment in planchet making and die putting did range from one coin to a different, and the necessity for getting a extra unified system was the intent of the ANA convention.

Official ANA Grading Standards for United States CoinsMost everybody who attended had a dialogue level that needed to be thought-about, however the members of the convention agreed that it may be worthwhile to undertake the SHELDON SYSTEM and use NUMERICAL GRADING along with the ADJECTIVAL LETTER DESIGNATION. Through the use of numbers together with letters, the system is perhaps clearer.

Dick Yeoman, the unique editor of the Redbook, and Ken Bressett, who was his shut Assistant, redid the grades as listed in the forthcoming concern of the Information E-book, and confirmed us a copy. It had one flaw, so far as I might see.

For, say, an About Uncirculated coin they stated AU 50, so the previous timer who was used to adjectival letters might perceive it and the newer collectors might work with the numerical aspect. It was an try and serve each teams. Nevertheless, when it got here to a Sensible Uncirculated coin, or BU, or BR UNC, the Information Guide we examined had MS 60. An unfamiliar phrase to most present collectors on the time.

I turned conscious of this distinction as a result of of its use in the public sale enterprise, however we felt the introduction of MS as an alternative of B U. or Br. Unc. can be questioned by those that have been used to the adjectival system, which for a lot of generations was a strategy to record an UNCIRCULATED COIN. So I advised to Ken: why not for the primary few years listing BOTH, a worth for the adjectival lettering, and in addition the numerical grade. It might certainly get the reader extra accustomed to the brand new grading system extra shortly than simply leaving an MS abbreviation with the brand new numerical grade.

After two weeks of calling Ken on the telephone at one pm (his native time, and after he completed his customary lunch hour), I satisfied him that it was necessary and can be very useful to his readers to simplify the grading in the Information E-book.

It took fairly a few years for the numerical half of the grade for use extra typically than no numbers in any respect, as collectors turned extra accustomed to seeing each in print and extra generally used, not restricted to only copper Giant Cents (because it was initially designed for), however to get recognition throughout the board for all U.S. cash. In fact, since that acceptance and utilization, it has develop into over the previous few many years extra acceptable and used to a a lot bigger extent.

Inside a brief time after this convention, the ANA established as a service to the pastime referred to as ANACS. For a payment, the ANA coin service would look at the specimens submitted, photograph every one, couple that photograph with every certificates of authenticity and return it to the sender. Nevertheless, because the coin and photograph weren’t hooked up, the photograph might be used for promoting false, altered, polished and poorer examples, after which the vendor would resubmit the coin to the service, and do it again and again.

The rip-off was quickly came upon, and the ANACS certification system was compromised and misplaced its significance.

By 1982 and ’83, two new providers got here into existence, PCGS, and NGC, they usually offered a grading service that featured a sealed container so switching cash and certificates was virtually unimaginable. Now there have been compromises even in this technique, which continues to be being labored on to today. However the try to beat fraud and mismarked gadgets has been tamed significantly inside the previous 30 years.

Lawrence Stack Joins the Workforce

Additionally in the spring of 1973, Lawrence R. Stack (Larry), my son, graduated from Ohio College, in Akron, Ohio, the place he majored in Historical past and Finance. Larry can also be the nephew of Joseph and the cousin of each Ben and Norman; this introduced 5 Stack’s again to working the enterprise (my father Morton, Larry’s grandfather, had died in 1967).

Larry throughout his earlier days, from public faculty and thru his college years–when time permitted–labored first as an apprentice after which as a full-time numismatist at Stack’s. He was taught the best way to purchase and promote, grade cash and cope with shoppers. He had the great fortune of assembly and turning into buddies with many of the senior collectors that used to go to weekly, in addition to being taught by a specialised employees (which Stack’s all the time had). He took to the educating and have become properly revered as a skilled numismatist inside a yr or two of turning into “full time”. Larry labored with the household in servicing and constructing collections, virtually managing the store and its many guests, whereas additionally accumulating sure collection of cash.

Larry constructed an expanded sort set of U.S. cash (modeled after the prize-profitable one which Norman developed and wrote a definitive guide about), a specialised assortment of Renaissance gold and silver, an historic gold and silver Greek and Roman collection, and a complete assortment of English gold and silver. Every when close to completion he bought at public sale, utilizing the funds to broaden his different collections. To him, they have been studying workouts that he loved doing, for not solely did assist develop a specialised love for every assortment, however turned very pleasant with collectors having comparable pursuits. He advocated “READ THE BOOK BEFORE YOU START COLLECTING”, which is what he did, and steered that others do the identical.

Larry now’s one of the founders of Stack’s Bowers, together with me and Q. Dave Bowers whom we merged with.

Noteworthy Auctions

With all of the modifications we have been concerned inside 1973, it’s straightforward to overlook we have been a enterprise. However Stack’s did maintain a collection of nice auctions that yr, with a number of thought-about, even as we speak, as necessary pedigree gross sales. Some of the cash from these 1973 gross sales have been resold at times and the pedigrees that they possess elevate many new collections. Let me listing a few spotlight gross sales with some of their options to offer you a higher concept as to how nice they have been.

The Nate Smith Collection - Stack's

In early March we provided the Nate Smith Assortment of some 1,879 tons, which featured a complete date and mint assortment for the overall collector.

Within the latter half of the month, we provided a complete assortment of Colonial and commonplace coinage, going again to the early days of our nation, the property of the Massachusetts Historic Society, which was deaccessing elements of the legendary Adams Household Assortment (assume of the founding father, not the creepy 1950s tv characters). Historical past was in the catalog, which provided some 1,204 tons!

In Might of 1973, we provided the famend C.H. Patten Assortment, which featured a whole lot of tons of U.S. half dollars from 1794, with the bulk of numerous die breaks in the Bust sort earlier than 1836, and different collection of fashionable curiosity. This sale had some 1,065 tons, in numerous grades and rarity.

Reed Hawn Collection - August 28, 29, 1973In August after the ANA Annual Conference, we had the privilege of providing one of probably the most well-known identify collections of that period: the famend assortment of Reed Hawn. A couple of many years earlier, Reed had come to go to Stack’s his father to start out constructing a tremendous-excessive-high quality assortment. The years throughout which he was assembling his assortment occurred to coincide with the sale of many well-known previous-time collections. Although he had a primary minor cash assortment in each Proof and Mint State, the spotlight of his assortment was the unbelievable array of Proof early points, from 1807, and highlights from 1794 to 1947 both in Proof or in excellent Mint State. To listing all of them can be prolonged, however to say some of the excellent rarities let me begin with 1794 via 1807, which have been principally Mint State, and included 1795, three totally different varieties; 1796 15 and 16 Star; 1797; 1801; and, from 1807, a giant group of varieties to 1836, all of which have been Mint State and selection, with some Proofs or first strikes. From 1836 to 1947, nearly full, highlighted by 1838-O in Proof; 1847/6; a run from 1850 to 1857 in Proof, together with an 1853 “O” in Presentation Proof grade; and all of the later dates in Mint State and Proof, together with the 1878-S in gem situation. Actually an UNRIVALED COLLECTION. The whole providing embraced some 808 tons and was one of the preferred and sought-after collections provided that yr.


In late November, one other main assortment of United States gold, silver, and copper cash, the property of George Scanlon, was awarded to Stack’s to promote. George was a fierce competitor in many of our gross sales and would sit in the again of the public sale room and bid strongly on many of the selection and uncommon cash we provided. He was a shopper of ours for over half a century, and initially began his assortment together with his grandchildren concerned. However when the youngsters began to develop up and didn’t absolutely perceive amassing and the values every coin had, George determined to promote. His large assortment had some 2,797 tons of particular person cash and units, particularly pre-1915 silver and copper Proof Units, acquired from some of our well-known earlier gross sales. George additionally had full runs of all collection principally in Mint State and Proof.

With two gross sales just like the Hawn and Scanlon Collections bought at public sale, along with three different basic collections (together with a main providing of Greek and Roman coinage), the agency had a fantastic yr and the honour of serving many collectors avidly constructing main collections themselves.

* * *

Hyperlinks to Earlier Elements:

1928-35 | 1935-45 | 1945-51 | 1951-52 | 1954 | 1955-56 | 1957 | 1958-59 | 1960 | 1961-62 | 1963 | 1964 | 1965 | 1966 | 1967 | 1968-69 | 1970-71 | 1972